Close Menu
  • News
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Institutional trading
    • Interviews
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
    • Prop Weekly
    • Marketing Newsletter
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
    • Regulations
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
  • Subscribe
LinkedIn WhatsApp YouTube
TradeInformer
Subscribe
  • News
    • Broker News
      • Funded Unicorn shut down notice on company homepage
        German prop firm Funded Unicorn shuts after “seven-figure loss” from a-book model
      • Trading 212 app
        Exclusive: clients at multiple UK brokers targeted in Ostin pump and dump fraud
      • XS.com CEO speaking to Al-Sabah TV in Kuwait
        XS opens office in Kuwait, CEO says broker “keen to open multiple offices in MENA”
    • Tech News
      • Devexperts
        EAERA Integrates with DXtrade to Deliver Seamless Broker CRM Solutions
      • cTrader post IFX Int website
        Spotware concludes a successful iFX expo international with Best Trading Platform Global 2025 award
      • Match-Trader
        Match-Trader launches new interface, will demo at iFX Expo this week
    • Institutional trading
      • Marco Maggioni Hirose financial executive
        Ex-Finalto, iSAM exec Marco Maggioni joins Hirose Financial prime team
      • simon halliday mas markets
        Scrum time: MAS Group hires ex-England rubgy international as Key Partnerships Adviser
      • John Murillo from B2BROKER
        B2BROKER’s Murillo: We have over 150 companies working with us for liquidity today
    • Interviews
      • Gareth Hazelden
        Atlantic Capital Markets: Cornwall, Dubai, and a 77k client database
      • Tom Fawcett Onyx Markets
        Building a new UK broker, with Onyx Markets Dealing Head Tom Fawcett
      • Todor Georgiev
        Exclusive: Todor Georgiev on launching prop firm Funded7
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
      • best forex brokers UK search in Google AI Mode
        Will AI kill forex broker affiliates?
      • Limassol
        Last week in Limassol: 5 takeaways from Cyprus
      • Hugo's Way
        Suicide Squad? Offshore brokers are targeting US clients – and nothing is happening to them
    • Prop Weekly
      • FTMO
        How much do Alpha Capital, FundedNext, FundingPips, and E8 Markets make?
      • Beijing
        Gold, prop firms and scammers in China
      • FTMO office
        How is FTMO so big?
    • Marketing Newsletter
      • Axi branding at Bahia football match
        Brokers are sponsoring EM sports teams
      • Pump those numbers
      • swissqote logo
        Does branding matter?
    • Guest Posts
      • XM prizes
        XM Is Giving $500,000 in Prizes to Worldwide Partners
      • PropShield Centroid Solutions
        Centroid Solutions Announces PropShield: A Centralized Intelligence Platform to Protect the Integrity of Prop Trading Challenges
      • Trade Tech Solutions: Revolutionizing Prop Firm Technology Under CEO Edoardo Dalla Torre
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
      • FTMO office
        How to start a prop firm for funded traders
      • Start a forex business (that isn’t a broker)
      • St Vincent and the Grenadines
        Cheapest country to start a forex broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
      • Mauritius airport
        FX/CFD license in Mauritius
      • Seychelles island
        Start a FX/CFD broker in the Seychelles
      • Labuan FSA
        Start a forex broker in Labuan
    • Liquidity
      • FXIFY Homepage
        What do prop trading firms do?
      • trading chart on a screen
        How do prop firms make money?
      • metatrader application on phone
        STP vs A-book for FX/CFD brokers
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
TradeInformer
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
Subscribe
Home » ATFunded responds: prop flow can be hedged

ATFunded responds: prop flow can be hedged

February 26, 20255 Mins Read Guest Posts
ATFunded homepage
Screenshot
Share
Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Telegram WhatsApp

A couple of weeks ago I wrote about managing prop flow, an article that gathered more of a response than I’d envisaged it would.

The ATFunded team disagreed with some of the points made in that article. I figured it would be fun to have them put their arguments into writing and have an article responding to mine.

So without further ado, here’s what the team at ATFunded had to say.

Prop flow can be hedged

After reviewing David Kimberley’s article, ATFunded offers a counter perspective drawn from our experience in the proprietary trading space. To address his arguments clearly, we’ve organized our rebuttal around his key points, providing insights from our operations.

Prop Trading and Sports Betting

Kimberley compares prop firms’ risk management to sportsbooks, where odds are adjusted and bet sizes capped to limit exposure. He suggests prop firms must constantly “move the needle,” sidelining skilled traders (the “card counters”) while relying on less sophisticated ones (like “Grandma Betty” with her coins). 

We see this as an oversimplification. Adjustments to rules often reflect initial frameworks that were too lenient, requiring temporary fixes. As newer models emerge with practical, tested rules—beyond mere marketing ploys—the need for frequent changes lessens. This reflects current market dynamics, not an inherent flaw in prop trading.

High Leverage in Prop Trading

Kimberley highlights that prop firms offer nominal leverage (e.g., 100:1), but with a 10% max loss limit, the effective leverage can appear much higher, such as 1000:1. He ties this to the concept of “buying drawdown,” but let’s clarify. 

Take a trader with a $100k account and a 10% drawdown cap. If they earn $10,500 in profit, their leverage doesn’t decrease—buying power remains tied to account size, not the inability to lose 100%. Hedged trades further challenge his view: leverage doesn’t scale as implied, yet trades still occur. This isn’t traditional leverage—it’s a distinct mechanism shaped by prop firm rules. Rather than mischaracterize it, we should recognize it as a unique risk tool.

Assessing Trader Skill

Kimberley argues that high leverage obscures the difference between skilled traders and gamblers, with rapid gains or losses clouding true ability. Evaluating skill in prop flow, particularly in pre-funded stages, can indeed be challenging—we agree. Most users mirror typical retail behavior and can be managed accordingly. The difficulty spikes during low-liquidity news events, where erratic trades distort the view. Remove those, and patterns emerge—like overnight range trading or longer-term swings. Filter out this noise, and the flow becomes more predictable, making skill assessment less like guessing and more data-driven. Context, not just leverage, is key.

Risk Management Challenges

Kimberley notes that, unlike traditional brokers with two-way flow, prop firms can’t adjust pricing to offset exposure, and hedging is complicated by high notional values and no client margin. Defining “risk management” for prop firms is critical. Not all flow can be hedged—correct—but risks differ. “Rule risk” stems from weak structures (e.g., 15% drawdown, no daily cap, 1:500 leverage, news trading permitted), setting firms up for failure when payouts exceed revenue. “Simulation risk” arises when accounts lack real market ties, as seen in firms hit by latency arbitrage. “Cheating risk” involves traders exploiting loopholes—like pre-news account buys or cross-firm opposite trades—addressed by limits or bans. Mitigate these, and “order flow risk” becomes more manageable, resembling retail patterns. Hedge outliers for profit, apply a C-book to the rest—it works with proper controls.

Potential for Significant Losses

Kimberley cautions that a failed high-leverage trade could severely impact a prop firm’s liquidity provider accounts. Losses are part of trading—no denying that. If hedged traders falter, it’s expensive but not catastrophic, thanks to pass rates and rules like daily or trailing drawdowns (e.g., 10% on a $100k account). 

A firm might hedge selectively—say, $100k across ten strong $100k accounts—capping risk while leveraging drawdown limits to moderate “effective leverage.” Unlike traditional brokers, prop firms can guide trader behavior, promoting consistency and education. Losses occur but are constrained by design.

Gambling Industry Analogy

Kimberley likens prop firms to casinos unable to hedge roulette, adjusting parameters to curb unhedgeable risks. Hedging is feasible—it just demands strategy. Prop hedging aligns with brokerage tactics but benefits from rules shaping flow and outcomes. Some firms may mimic a casino model, but that’s not the norm. A trader hitting payouts with hedgeable traits can create mutual gains. Drawdown rules—far from mere leverage amplifiers—limit downside, enabling firms to pass viable flow to markets profitably. 

Our ATFunded+ program shows this: profiling flow and integrating top traders into copy trading reduces risk, boosts volume, and balances the equation. It’s calculated, not a gamble.

Conclusion

Prop order flow can be hedged with robust rules, effective systems, and capable teams to handle its nuances. As technology and models advance, growing familiarity with customer flow will enhance hedging and alpha generation. Kimberley’s critique highlights today’s obstacles, but ongoing innovation is steadily peeling away the “unhedgeable” label.

ATFunded ATFX
Previous ArticleOneRoyal partners with ex-Man Utd player Diego Forlan
Next Article Acuity Trading partners with DB Investing

Related Posts

ATFX Releases Q3 2025 Trader Magazine: Your Essential Guide to Global Markets in Uncertain Times

July 2, 2025

ATFX takes part in Asia Precious Metals Conference in Singapore

June 26, 2025

XM Is Giving $500,000 in Prizes to Worldwide Partners

June 23, 2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Latest News

German prop firm Funded Unicorn shuts after “seven-figure loss” from a-book model

Broker News July 3, 2025

Funded Unicorn said in a statement sent to clients that traders on live accounts caused the firm huge losses that have put it out of business.

Exclusive: clients at multiple UK brokers targeted in Ostin pump and dump fraud

July 3, 2025

Ex-Finalto, iSAM exec Marco Maggioni joins Hirose Financial prime team

July 3, 2025
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
  • News
    • Newsletters
    • Interviews
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
  • Follow
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    • WhatsApp
© 2025 TradeInformer

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Ad Blocker Enabled!
Ad Blocker Enabled!
Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.