Close Menu
  • News
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Institutional trading
    • Interviews
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
    • Prop Weekly
    • Marketing Newsletter
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
    • Regulations
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
  • Subscribe
LinkedIn WhatsApp YouTube
TradeInformer
Subscribe
  • News
    • Broker News
      • Exness branded youtube thumbnail for india
        Exness stops onboarding clients in India
      • crypto.com arena
        Exclusive: Crypto.com hires Leven Li to head MENA compliance
      • Damon Sze topwealthtrading managing director
        Ex-Hantec COO Damon Sze joins TopWealthTrading as Managing Director
    • Tech News
      • Fortress Core Connect and Shufti Pro branding
        Fortress Core Connect partners with Shufti Pro for AML/KYC technology
      • Team Force Technologies logo
        TeamForce Technologies integrates tech stack with cTrader platform
      • Trade Tech Solutions branding on black background
        Reward systems: The Game-Changer in prop trading technology
    • Institutional trading
      • Hilbert Group
        TradeLocker owner Deus X Capital invests $31m in Hilbert Group’s crypto treasury programme
      • ATFX Duke of Edinburgh
        ATFX Connect Joins the Duke of Edinburgh Cup City of London Qualifier 
      • Fortress Core Connect
        Fortress Core Connect gets FSCA License, strengthening local footprint in South Africa
    • Interviews
      • Yiota Hadjilouka from cTrader speaking at a panel at iFX Expo 2025
        Spotware COO: Almost 50% of new traders download cTrader Store products
      • Sam Eder, founder of broker MarketMates
        MarketMates Founder on prop, getting an ASIC license, and helping clients succeed
      • Gareth Hazelden
        Atlantic Capital Markets: Cornwall, Dubai, and a 77k client database
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
      • Taxi in New Delhi
        Plus500 options, India, event contracts, and MAGA
      • best forex brokers UK search in Google AI Mode
        Will AI kill forex broker affiliates?
      • Limassol
        Last week in Limassol: 5 takeaways from Cyprus
    • Prop Weekly
      • Instant Funding $5,000 free challenge giveaway advertising
        Instant Funding $5,000 giveaway – 5,000 accounts, $500,000 in marketing spend
      • Trader Thomas Hartmann, owner of prop firm Funded Unicorn
        Did Funded Unicorn just cut and run with traders’ money?
      • TraxNYC picture from website
        Alpha Prime, diamond dealers, and Million Dollar Traders
    • Marketing Newsletter
      • Axi branding at Bahia football match
        Brokers are sponsoring EM sports teams
      • Pump those numbers
      • swissqote logo
        Does branding matter?
    • Guest Posts
      • Stanislav Galandzovskyi paid marketing specialist
        Where prop firms should (and shouldn’t) be looking next for growth
      • XM prizes
        XM Is Giving $500,000 in Prizes to Worldwide Partners
      • PropShield Centroid Solutions
        Centroid Solutions Announces PropShield: A Centralized Intelligence Platform to Protect the Integrity of Prop Trading Challenges
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
      • FTMO office
        How to start a prop firm for funded traders
      • Start a forex business (that isn’t a broker)
      • St Vincent and the Grenadines
        Cheapest country to start a forex broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
      • Mauritius airport
        FX/CFD license in Mauritius
      • Seychelles island
        Start a FX/CFD broker in the Seychelles
      • Labuan FSA
        Start a forex broker in Labuan
    • Liquidity
      • trading chart on a screen
        How do prop firms make money?
      • FXIFY Homepage
        What do prop trading firms do?
      • metatrader application on phone
        STP vs A-book for FX/CFD brokers
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
TradeInformer
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
Subscribe
Home » Fineco, eToro and the €1.3m fine

Fineco, eToro and the €1.3m fine

July 24, 20235 Mins Read Newsletters
Fineco Bank logo
Share
Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Telegram WhatsApp

Readers of this newsletter may know that eToro was fined €1.3m by an Italian anti-trust regulator (AGCM) earlier this month.

For those unaware of this, the high level problem was that eToro advertised stock trading as ‘commission-free’ to investors in Italy, when in reality they did have to pay some costs around FX and transfers.

This happened to providers in the UK a couple of years ago, which is why a lot of them stopped doing it or put other information around the ‘commission-free’ stuff to show that there were other costs involved when buying stocks.

However, reading through the full case against eToro is interesting for several reasons.

One is that Fineco Bank actually joined the suit and provided information that was used against eToro. The spirt of friendly competition!

The main points Fineco made were essentially the same as those made by the AGCM, namely that…

  • eToro wasn’t being transparent about costs
  • Shares were non-transferrable
  • The way they were marketed would have enabled them to cross sell “complex products”

If we start with the first point, I understand why the regulator is annoyed but I also have some sympathy for the ‘commission-free’ slogan. Most people seem to associate ‘commission’ in this context with ‘dealing fees’ or ‘execution fees’, so it doesn’t seem misleading to use the phrase in reference to those charges. Also ‘execution free’ doesn’t make for great ad copy.

But then some of eToro’s stocks weren’t commission free apparently. And regardless of what I think, it’s clear regulators don’t like this stuff – so it may be wiser for brokers to avoid doing it (or provide more info if you do).

However, the shares being non-transferrable is more of a valid point. The inability to transfer your shares out of a company is bad practice and does effectively bake in an extra cost if you ever want to do that. If you had any funds in a tax-efficient account, like an ISA, it would also mean you lose that allowance if you were forced to transfer into cash.

The broad sense you get from the regulator here is that they just don’t like it, with one of the things highlighted being that you cannot access voting rights attached to shares. One weird thing, to be fair to eToro, was that they criticised the company for not telling customers that you don’t get dividends if you bought shares after the ex-div date…which is how that works?

Anyway, the other facet they looked at here was to criticise it as an additional cost that customers had to pay. Basically if an investor wanted to transfer shares, they’d be forced to sell, incur FX and withdrawal fees in the process, then buy back, which would result in paying the spread and (potentially) dealing costs.

Aside from saying this acts as a kind of fee, the regulator also noted that the inability to transfer shares wasn’t made clear to prospective customers. Had it been, then it’s plausible they’d have decided not to invest.

This points to a couple of things. One is the operational costs associated with adding equities trading. In simple terms, this is not like CFDs, which can be manufactured relatively easily and where you don’t have to worry about things like custody, nominee accounts, exchange connections and so on.

The other is that this is just another factor that brokers will have to be cognisant of when adding equities. Regulators don’t like it in general if you don’t allow customers to transfer out. Now we know they also don’t like it if you don’t allow them to do it and market the service as being commission-free.

Now the final point about cross selling. I know many of you will be shocked – truly shocked – to learn that some providers use the ability to sell stocks as a way of circumventing marketing restrictions and cross selling other products.

The first thing is that it’s kind of hilarious Fineco complained about eToro doing this considering they were doing pretty much exactly the same thing during the pandemic. I also seem to recall similar banner ads popping up when I was in Italy towards the end of last year. The only reason I can think of that this particularly annoyed Fineco is that they do charge dealing fees, so maybe they felt eToro was stealing clients from them.

However, the ‘positive’ here is that the regulator actually didn’t look at this point. In other words, they didn’t look into the fact that eToro customers may have been able to switch too easily into leveraged products – although the caveat here is that the AGCM is not a financial regulator, so it may be something that crops up down the line.

Some other interesting info was also in the case doc. One is that eToro’s Cypriot entity was loss-making last year. The AGCM actually reduced the fine €200,000 because of this.

Following up on that, I had a look at eToro’s most recent investor presentation deck. Aside from not providing any information on revenues or profit/loss for last year, this was also interesting because it showed the company is applying for licences in Singapore, Abu Dhabi, Germany and Spain.

etoro Fineco
Previous ArticleSpain’s CFD ban
Next Article Interview with Skilling CEO Michael Kamerman

Related Posts

Plus500 options, India, event contracts, and MAGA

July 14, 2025

IG Group partners with Pat Cash for new stock market campaign

July 1, 2025

Will AI kill forex broker affiliates?

June 30, 2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Latest News

Instant Funding $5,000 giveaway – 5,000 accounts, $500,000 in marketing spend

Prop Weekly July 18, 2025

Instant Funding is giving away unlimited free $5k challenges until it gets 5,000 funded accounts. Here’s why they’re doing it and how it works.

Spotware COO: Almost 50% of new traders download cTrader Store products

July 18, 2025

Exness stops onboarding clients in India

July 17, 2025
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
  • News
    • Newsletters
    • Interviews
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
  • Follow
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    • WhatsApp
© 2025 TradeInformer

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Ad Blocker Enabled!
Ad Blocker Enabled!
Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.