Close Menu
  • News
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Institutional trading
    • Interviews
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
    • Prop Weekly
    • Marketing Newsletter
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
    • Regulations
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
  • Subscribe
LinkedIn WhatsApp YouTube
TradeInformer
Subscribe
  • News
    • Broker News
      • FXPrimus synthetic indices trading branding
        FXPrimus Launches Synthetic Indices
      • Bogdan Nicolae Albu from Admiral Markets
        Admirals Regional Director Bogdan Albu leaves broker after six years
      • plus500 ad italy
        Options and futures make up 13% of Plus500 H1 revenue
    • Tech News
      • adclear homepage screenshot
        ActivTrades starts using Adclear to auto-comply marketing comms
      • DXtrade mobile app homescreen and account details
        DXtrade upgrades mobile interface, makes WebView integrations possible
      • Devexperts
        EAERA Integrates with DXtrade to Deliver Seamless Broker CRM Solutions
    • Institutional trading
      • Michael Mirarchi with ATFX Connect LATAM branding
        ATFX Connect Appoints Michael Mirarchi as Managing Director of Institutional Sales, LATAM
      • Ryan Oliver Rostro Group trading
        Rostro Group hires Oliver Ryan as Head of Trading Operations
      • Neil Panbari
        CME Group hires Neil Pabari as Head of APAC Retail Sales and Distribution
    • Interviews
      • Sam Eder, founder of broker MarketMates
        MarketMates Founder on prop, getting an ASIC license, and helping clients succeed
      • Gareth Hazelden
        Atlantic Capital Markets: Cornwall, Dubai, and a 77k client database
      • Tom Fawcett Onyx Markets
        Building a new UK broker, with Onyx Markets Dealing Head Tom Fawcett
  • Analysis
    • Newsletters
      • best forex brokers UK search in Google AI Mode
        Will AI kill forex broker affiliates?
      • Limassol
        Last week in Limassol: 5 takeaways from Cyprus
      • Hugo's Way
        Suicide Squad? Offshore brokers are targeting US clients – and nothing is happening to them
    • Prop Weekly
      • TraxNYC picture from website
        Alpha Prime, diamond dealers, and Million Dollar Traders
      • FTMO
        How much do Alpha Capital, FundedNext, FundingPips, and E8 Markets make?
      • Beijing
        Gold, prop firms and scammers in China
    • Marketing Newsletter
      • Axi branding at Bahia football match
        Brokers are sponsoring EM sports teams
      • Pump those numbers
      • swissqote logo
        Does branding matter?
    • Guest Posts
      • XM prizes
        XM Is Giving $500,000 in Prizes to Worldwide Partners
      • PropShield Centroid Solutions
        Centroid Solutions Announces PropShield: A Centralized Intelligence Platform to Protect the Integrity of Prop Trading Challenges
      • Trade Tech Solutions: Revolutionizing Prop Firm Technology Under CEO Edoardo Dalla Torre
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
      • FTMO office
        How to start a prop firm for funded traders
      • Start a forex business (that isn’t a broker)
      • St Vincent and the Grenadines
        Cheapest country to start a forex broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
      • Mauritius airport
        FX/CFD license in Mauritius
      • Seychelles island
        Start a FX/CFD broker in the Seychelles
      • Labuan FSA
        Start a forex broker in Labuan
    • Liquidity
      • FXIFY Homepage
        What do prop trading firms do?
      • trading chart on a screen
        How do prop firms make money?
      • metatrader application on phone
        STP vs A-book for FX/CFD brokers
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
TradeInformer
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
Subscribe
Home » Will the FCA kill CFDs?

Will the FCA kill CFDs?

January 6, 20256 Mins Read Newsletters
fca hq
Share
Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Telegram WhatsApp
cTrader banner

Get your broker listed on TradingView with cTrader

Something you often read about the UK is that it’s in a state of ‘managed decline’. Basically the country faces insurmountable problems and so the best the government can do is let it gradually get worse, without the shock of a ‘hard’ landing.

I don’t know if that’s true but as I walk around London I often think of that quote from the first Pirates of the Caribbean film, except instead of a skeleton man yelling at Keira Knightley, it’s a barber in a Hoodrich puffer jacket walking out of a vape shop, shouting it at me – ‘you best start believing in emerging markets Mr Kimberley – you’re in one!’

Anyway, one component of managed decline is the regulator slowly killing off businesses. And last month the Financial Conduct Authority put out a ‘Dear CEO’ letter for companies in the CFD industry. A couple of people I spoke to had the usual gloomy retorts – ‘writing is on the wall’, ‘industry is done’ etc etc. Is that true? Is this managed decline?

Looking for a new LP? Talk to ATFX Connect

The letter makes a few points that are worth considering. First up, 100 companies used the post-Brexit ‘temporary permissions’ regime to keep doing business in the UK. Zero companies got full authorisation after that regime ended (lol).

No more license for branding

Another key point was what the FCA calls ‘Halo firms’. These are basically inactive entities that companies use for branding / marketing, to show that they are a higher quality business because of the respectability that an FCA license (in theory) confers. They then onboard clients offshore. We’ve looked at this before when working out if it’s better to get an FCA license or sponsor a Premier League team.

Match-Trader Banner advert

Get a Match-Trader server today

The FCA has said they don’t like this and will force companies doing it to either start using the license in a normal way or shut shop. Incidentally, this seems to be something CySEC has done as well, which is why you are seeing some firms say they are ‘B2B only’ or giving up their license entirely.

The other interesting part of the FCA’s discussion here was that they said they treat takeover efforts as equivalent to an application for a new firm. In other words, buying an existing entity is not really a backdoor to getting a license.

Launch copy trading on cTrader and MetaTrader with Brokeree

Is this a disaster? I don’t think so. This apparently affects 20% of the companies in the UK industry. But if you aren’t doing business with the entity, it’s hard to argue that your business is being killed because there is nothing there to kill. You weren’t using the license anyway!

Not using pro money for hedging

Perhaps the most significant change that the FCA has hinted at is changes to how client money is held.

The main ‘problem’ here relates to clients that have pro status entering into Title Transfer Collateral Arrangements (‘TTCAs’) with brokers. These allow the broker to use the client’s deposit to post margin with whoever they are hedging with. This could include one of their own entities.

I get the impression that for a lot of companies, if this is banned, then it’s ‘GG – see you later’. Two executives told me that this would be the death knell or close to it for smaller firms if they have to do this.

But then the FCA didn’t say that they would ban it. They just said don’t do it in a way that breaches regulations.

It is hard to say if that will change but I think it ultimately won’t. Working in this industry means you can often operate in a silo and forget there is a much larger financial services industry operating outside of your purview (I am saying this for me too, so don’t feel offended!)

Pro client status impacts many, many other things too. For example, if you want to invest in a lot of hedge funds in the UK as an individual, you cannot do it unless you have pro status. I don’t think you could chisel out a weird, unique ban on TTCAs purely for pros trading CFDs because it could have unintended, knock on effects elsewhere.

No surprises

The other points the FCA makes in the letter were, to my mind, just not that surprising or unexpected.

One of the themes could be summed up as ‘if you offer different products and grow, make sure you have systems to handle the large number of new clients.’ Another was more Consumer Duty stuff about appropriateness.

None of this looked that new to me. To my mind, the main takeaway is that the regulatory burden will continue to grow and if you are not big, you will not be able to handle it, because of both the cost and the human resources needed to do so.

I don’t like that and it makes me annoyed that a regulator is basically killing competition – particularly as their remit is to increase it.

However, if I contrast this with some European countries, which I think could ban CFDs, I don’t think it will happen in the UK. You have to keep in mind the fact that there are three large firms listed on the London Stock Exchange who continue to have CFDs as their primary product. XTB’s size also means Poland will not ban them and is why the regulator there gave allowances for higher leverage.

A better analogy is the US. Over in the Land of the Free, exchange lobbies and a clear disdain on the part of the regulator, made it so capital intensive to offer leveraged FX for retail that there are now only a handful of companies that do so. The goal seems to have been, not to kill the industry entirely, but make it far more concentrated, so that it was less of a headache and easier for the regulator to manage.

The FCA is probably hoping to achieve something similar. They are slowly adding incremental pressure to reach a point where only a small number of players are active in the industry. It’s less about managed decline and more about them not wanting the ‘headache’ of having to deal with loads of small firms. If you look at the UK retail stockbroking sector, there are really only three companies of any significant size and then 10 – 20 smaller firms. That is probably what the FCA is hoping for with CFDs.

Previous ArticleBrokeree integrates Social Trading with cTrader
Next Article Capital.com hires IG product manager

Related Posts

Will AI kill forex broker affiliates?

June 30, 2025

Last week in Limassol: 5 takeaways from Cyprus

June 23, 2025

Suicide Squad? Offshore brokers are targeting US clients – and nothing is happening to them

June 16, 2025
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Latest News

MarketMates Founder on prop, getting an ASIC license, and helping clients succeed

Interviews July 9, 2025

We talk to Sam Eder about his new broker MarketMates, why he started the company, and what it has been like to launch a new broker in 2025.

ActivTrades starts using Adclear to auto-comply marketing comms

July 9, 2025

ATFX Connect Appoints Michael Mirarchi as Managing Director of Institutional Sales, LATAM

July 8, 2025
YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
  • News
    • Newsletters
    • Interviews
    • Broker News
    • Tech News
    • Guest Posts
  • Learn
    • Start a broker
    • FX CFD Licensing
    • Liquidity
  • About
    • What is TradeInformer
    • Who runs TradeInformer?
    • Contact
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
  • Follow
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    • WhatsApp
© 2025 TradeInformer

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Ad Blocker Enabled!
Ad Blocker Enabled!
Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.